New format
How to find a marketer: agency, in-house, and what to check
You need a marketer not for show, but to link channels to sales: traffic, offer, analytics, experiments. Without a clear brief any candidate or agency will work into the void.
Below: where to look, how an agency differs from in-house/freelance, what to check in interviews, and how to talk about money and KPIs. What a digital agency covers is in a separate piece.
Agency: pros and cons
Pros: faster to find an executor, a team with different roles, a fresh outside view. Cons: longer immersion into the brand’s language, risk of a formal relationship without KPIs and regular calls.
Look not only at a famous name, but who will run the account, how they count results, and how they hand knowledge to in-house.
Searching on your own
Job boards, referrals, communities, former colleagues — longer selection, but you can know the person deeper before a contract. Hiring and onboarding decisions sit fully on you.
Look for someone who can create and measure commercial traffic for your goal — not only “run socials for mood.”
What a candidate should show:
- basics in the needed channel (paid search, SEO, SMM — by task)
- cases with role and numbers
- understanding of the market and limits
- readiness to work with analytics and reporting
Money, KPIs, and the team
Rate grows with level and ownership area. First lock tasks and expected effect — then find people for that vector. In the budget put not only salary/retainer, but media spend and narrow vendors (design, build, call tracking).
A good marketer often brings a network of specialists. Agree in advance: whose contacts, who pays, who approves estimates. KPIs (bonus added to base pay) usually motivate better than pay “for any lead” without quality.
FAQ
Should you hire an agency or your own marketer?
An agency covers the stack and load peaks faster. In-house knows the product deeper. Often a hybrid: strategy/channels outside, product and approvals inside.
Is “knows paid search” enough as a hiring criterion?
For a narrow job — yes. For business growth you also need landings, analytics, offer, and funnel understanding. Clarify ownership in the brief.
How do you verify experience?
Cases with numbers and the person’s role, questions “what broke and how you fixed it,” a paid test on your data. “10,000 hours” is a metaphor, not a filter.
Should you pay per lead or a fixed fee?
Depends on tracking maturity. Fixed plus KPI/bonus is clearer than “leads only” with no quality control. In the contract — lead definitions and exclusions.
How much creative freedom do they need?
Yes in experiments, but within budget, brand, and KPIs. “Spend as much as you want” isn’t freedom — it’s risk.
Where should a client start the search?
Describe the goal, budget, current channels, and what you’ve already tried. The clearer the brief, the easier to find the right specialist.
Hiring “someone who knows ads” — and still no KPI or ownership?
We’ll lock the brief, format (agency/in-house/hybrid), and measurable KPIs — cases over hour myths.
Discuss the task
